Big, paper-thin slices from your home oven. Get the largest screens that your oven can fit; don’t scale this down, ya jabroni. Let’s make some genuine NY-style pizza
New York Style Pizza

Two 17" pizzas

baking pizza dinner

Ingredients

Dough

  • 600 g bread flour
  • 371 g water
  • 12 g salt
  • 9 g olive oil
  • 6 g sugar
  • 3/4 tsp instant yeast

Sauce

Cheese

  • low-moisture, whole-milk mozzarella
  • parmesan reggiano or pecorino romano

Day 1 - Dough

  1. In mixer bowl, mix water with salt, sugar, and instant yeast. Stir until dissolved. Add flour and stir until mostly combined
  2. Fit mixer with dough hook and mix on lowest speed for one minute. Slowly add olive oil, with mixer running. Increase mixer to speed 2 and mix for 5 minutes. Stop mixer and cover with large bag for 10 minutes. Mix on speed 2 for 5 more minutes. Stop mixer, remove dough hook, and shape dough into a ball. Put back into mixer bowl and cover for 15 minutes
  3. Grease counter and dough containers. Divide dough into 2 pieces, weighing ~500g each. Shape into tight balls, pinching the bottom to seal if needed. Place into containers seam side down, and move to fridge for 72-96 hours

Day 4 or 5 - Pizza Day

  1. Pizza Prep (-90 min) => set oven to max, with stones/steels in place. Remove dough containers from fridge. Shred cheese and prepare toppings. Get out peel, screens, and flour. Lightly grease pizza screens for insurance
  2. Stretch => dust counter and top of dough ball with flour. Put container upside-down and tap on counter to release dough ball. Add flour and flip dough so top side is on top. Use finger tips to press dough towards the edges. Don’t press the center too much. Flip and repeat 2 times. Top side should be back on top. Lift dough off counter and toss between your hands while rotating, like in this video, until it’s roughly the size of the screen. Lay onto screen and use both hands to go around and stretch sections to fit the screen. Look for thicker sections and get them stretched to match. Repeat for 2nd pizza
  3. Dress => pour 1 cup sauce into middle and spread almost to edges, with a spoon or clean hands. The dough is very thin, so work with care. Add relatively-light layer of cheese. You should be able to see the sauce throughout. Top with pepperoni or whatever. Repeat for 2nd pizza
  4. Bake (~7 min) => Move pizza screens to oven, centering on the stones/steels. Bake for 2-3 minutes. Use peel and oven glove to rotate screens 180°. Bake for 2-3 minutes. Slide pizzas off screens, by sliding the peel between them, and using the oven glove to remove the screen. Peek at the bottoms. If the bottoms are done but the tops are not, turn on broiler. Bake for another 1-2 minutes, keeping a close eye, until tops are done.
  5. Finish => move pizzas to cooling racks. Top with grated parm/pecorino and oregano. Slice and serve hot